That pretty much narrows it down to the two finalists I've been considering. Now that I know that I can sync my contacts to Outlook via the software application it's really giving the Impression the edge.
While the Fuze may indeed have a VGA screen, it's so small as to make that advantage almost moot. Plus it lacks the contrast and brightness of the Impressions OLED screen. Couple that with the fact it has no touchscreen feedback and the Impression seems to be the way to go if I don't need the Windows Mobile OS.
Plus the data plan for the Samsung is $20-$30 a month cheaper and optional than the data plan for the Fuze which AT&T forces you to purchase.