Posted Sept. 12, 2004 by Lisa Gade, Editor
in Chief Page 2, continued from page 1
Gaming and Multimedia Performance
Though the iPAQ doesn't win in the speed race,
it's surprisingly pleasant to use for gaming. Bust
'Em 2, Blade of Betrayal, Handmark
Trivial Pursuit, Sim City 2000, WarFare
Inc. and EverQuest ran well,
but Metalion 2 would not launch
(it seems to only run on Intel ARM and XScale processsors). Unless
you're running game emulators (which are very processor intensive)
or games that require four front mappable buttons, the iPAQ should
suffice.
As with all Pocket PCs, you can use the included
Pocket version of Windows Media Player for MP3 and Windows Media
format movie playback. There are several other MP3 players on the
market you can also use (reviewed here), and I do recommend the
free Pocket MVP if you're a video buff. PocketMVP (Pocket
Music and Video Player) plays DivX, MPEG, AVI and MP3 files. In
addition, PocketTV is
an excellent app for MPEG1 movie playback and it integrates with
Pocket IE for MPEG1 movies you might find on the web.
Using PocketTV
Enterprise Edition to play "The Chosen" (a neat
BMW flick with Clive Owen) which is a 4:26 minute long, 10 meg
MPEG1 file recorded at 320 x 240, 308 kb/s, the iPAQ managed
a respectable 24.13 fps. PocketMVP played "The
Chosen" at 23.46 fps, and dropped 144 out of 6394 frames.
The 6315 played the Spider Man trailer file commonly found on
the web (240 x 136, 452Kb/s encoded MPEG 1 file) at 22.06 fps
and dropped a more lackluster 214 out of 2640 frames, though
the film looked good during playback. My own test MPEG1 file
burned from a DVD at a whopping 700 Kb/s didn't look smooth in
playback and suffered a high percentage of dropped frames. It
played back at 8.5 fps. PocketTV did a better job, playing back
at a watchable 16.7 fps. In comparison, the XDA II (currently
the fastest Pocket PC phone) played the same movie at 23.97 fps
using PocketTV Enterprise and PocketMVP. The XDA II has an ATI
graphics chip for which both PocketTV and PocketMVP have optimizations.
If you're a video fan using PocketMVP, I'd recommend
playing movies encoded at 300 Kb/s-- if you go significantly higher,
playback quality will suffer. Using PocketTV Enterprise, you can
go higher, but I'd say that 300 Kb/s is the target for fast
and smooth playback for all players and movie media types. If you
burn your own DVDs to Pocket PC format and love watching high quality
videos encoded at 600 Kb/s on the PDA, the iPAQ 6315 might not
be the best choice since its video playback isn't superior.
Display and Sound
Score another big point for the 6315: it has the most outdoor
viewable display I've seen in years on a PDA. Like other Pocket
PCs and many Palm OS PDAs, it has a transflective display that
offers very good color saturation, contrast and indoor viewability.
It's a standard Pocket PC 240 x 320 QVGA resolution display with
a 3.5" LCD. While many have noted how viewable the display is outdoors,
some have described their displays as "milky". Ours is not milky
in the least and looks great when viewing photos and videos. It's
very bright, and at 50% brightness, should be bright enough for
most folks. The iPAQ's display isn't as stunning as the XDA II's,
but it certainly looks great and nothing beats it for outdoor viewing,
which is important for a device that's also a phone.
Sound on the other hand, isn't impressive. The
6315's volume level is surprisingly low for a convergence device,
and that's a big minus because we need to easily hear the phone
ringing and hear conversations. It's a mystery why HP didn't go
for a loud speaker on a device that doubles as a phone. If you're
in a room that have average noise or less, you'll have no trouble
hearing phone conversations with phone volume set to max or one
notch below.The Samsung i700 and XDA II are much louder using the
internal speaker. If you're in a very noisy environment, consider
using a headset (wired or Bluetooth) which offers much better sound
volume. Call recipients had no trouble hearing us, on the other
hand, and the mic is more than adequate.
The problem with sound volume seems to be software
related, since I used an audio editor to increase the volume of my ringtones
and alerts, and now I never miss the phone ringing or an alarm. Perhaps
HP will offer an updater to improve sound volume.
The iPAQ has a rear firing speaker for alarms and system
sounds, so you won't be deafened by these should they go off when you're
in a phone conversation. The phone speaker is located above the display
in the black plastic cap, and the mic is located on the bottom, next
to the Contacts button. The snap on keyboard has a hole for the mic,
so you can use the phone with keyboard without degrading sound. The iPAQ has a vibrate function.
Like other iPAQs, the unit has an iPAQ Audio
control panel applet that allows you to adjust treble and bass output,
use AGC (automatic gain control) for the mic or set gain manually.
When listening to MP3s and videos through a set of stereo headphones,
sound is excellent and the volume is more than adequate. Unlike other
smartphones, the iPAQ has a standard 3.5mm headphone jack commonly
found on non-phone Pocket PCs, so you can plug in your favorite set
of headphones to listen to tunes. HP includes a 2.5 to 3.5mm adapter
in the box so you can use standard mobile phone headsets and they also
include a mono cell phone headset with earbud and mic (but no call
send and end buttons).
Battery Life
The iPAQ has an 1,800 mAh Lithium Ion battery, which
is a large capacity for a standard battery. A 3,600 mAh extended battery
is available for purchase separately, and that battery slides in place
of the standard battery, increasing the phone's thickness. Most folks
probably won't need the extended battery because battery life on this
device is truly exceptional for a Pocket PC phone and even for a Palm
OS smartphone both of which require nightly charging. The iPAQ runs twice as long as the powerhouse XDA II (aka i Mate Pocket PC Phone), and with light phone use with all wireless features turned on, can achieve 7 hours of continuous usage.
To test battery life, I made approximately 10
calls lasting 30 minutes total, left both WiFi and Bluetooth turned on
all day, used the device frequently for PIM lookups, playing four
~ 8 minute movies and surfed the web using WiFi for an hour. The 6315
still had 65% charge at day's end. To top it off, I used a Bluetooth
headset for one half of those calls, which drains more power than using
the internal speaker and mic. I did another WiFi test session, with the
battery level starting at 68% and I surfed the web using NetFront
3.1 for an hour and the battery level dropped to 55%. That's
miraculous! Using other Pocket PCs and WiFi, an hour generally consumes
40% or more power, even with CPU power savings (drops the clock speed
down) enabled. I have no idea how HP has managed this feat, but it is
indeed liberating! For all tests, screen brightness was set to 55%, which
was bright enough to suit us at the office. No Pocket PC comes close
to standard feature phone runtimes except the iPAQ. Though the average
GSM camera phone with Bluetooth can still make it to three days between
charges if you're a light phone, camera and PIM user while the iPAQ will
likely need a charge every other day with light use. Comparisons between
smartphones and feature phones aren't that straight forward because folks
tend to use the PDA functions several times a day on smartphones while
feature phones don't even offer these functions.
Keyboard
HP includes a snap on thumb keyboard, which is ingenious.
Prefer a smaller phone and have no need for the keyboard— leave
it at home. Need that keyboard all the time for emails and instant messaging,
keep it clipped on the phone. Sometimes need
just the phone and need a keyboard at others? Carry the phone keyboard-less,
but keep that keyboard in your purse or pocket for times when you need
it. A very versatile design that will suit most everyone. Thankfully,
the keyboard is larger than the Treo 600's, which is as small as a keyboard
can go while remaining at all useful. The keyboard is a bit smaller than
most accessory thumb keyboards sold separately by 3rd party manufacturers,
so it doesn't add that much bulk yet it is quite usable. HP hit a good
middle ground with this design.
The keyboard driver is pre-installed, so you need only
snap the keyboard onto the iPAQ and begin typing. You can turn the driver
off if you wish, turn on key clicks and adjust repeat rate. This driver
also works with HP's Folding Keyboard, though when detaching that keyboard,
sometimes the iPAQ thinks it's still there, so disable the keyboard driver
before disconnecting the HP Folding Keyboard (this isn't necessary with
the thumb keyboard).
The keyboard has round, domed keys that don't require
a great deal of pressure to push and click lightly when depressed. It's
a standard QWERTY layout with an embedded number pad and the number keys
are a darker shade of gray. The keyboard's blue function key enables
numbers, punctuation and foreign symbols which are masked in blue on
the keys. You don't have to hold down the function when entering a phone
number. Instead you can turn on Fn key lock by pressing the blue key
twice so you can dial a phone number in the phone app or enter a long
string of numbers in Excel. To disable Fn lock, simply press the blue
key once more. The keyboard also has embedded arrow keys, buttons for
call send and end and Contacts and Email buttons. Unfortunately, the
keys aren't backlit, so you won't be able to type in dark or dimly lit
rooms.
Next-> Go
to Review Page 3(WiFi,
Bluetooth, camera, software, comparisons and conclusion)
Jump To:
Specs:
Display:Transflective
TFT color LCD, 64K colors, Screen Size Diag: 3.5",
Resolution: 240 x 320.
Battery:Lithium
Ion Polymer rechargeable. Battery is user replaceable.
1000 mA. 1800 mA extended battery available for purchase.
Performance:Intel
XScale PXA 255 400 MHz processor. 64 MB built-in RAM
(55 megs available). 32 MB Flash ROM with 2.85 megs
available in File Store for your use.
Size:4.47
x 2.78 x .53 in. Weight: 4.67 oz.
Audio:Built
in speaker, mic and 3.5mm standard stereo headphone
jack. Voice Recorder and Windows Pocket Media Player
9 included for your MP3 pleasure.
Networking:Integrated
WiFi 802.11b (also supporting LEAP) and Bluetooth.
Software:Pocket
PC 2003 Premium operating system (aka Windows Mobile
2003). Microsoft Pocket Office suite including Pocket
Word, Excel, Internet Explorer, and Outlook. Also,
Terminal Services, MSN Instant Messenger for Pocket
PC, MS Reader and Voice Recorder as well as handwriting
recognition. 3rd party software: Westtek ClearVue Suite,
F-Secure FileCrypto Data Encryption, Colligo Personal
Edition, Adobe PDF Viewer, RealOne Player for Pocket
PC, iPresenter PowerPoint converter, MobiMate WorldMate.
ActiveSync 3.7 and Outlook 2002 for PCs included.
Expansion:1
SD (Secure Digital) slot, 4 bit data bus, supporting
SDIO and SDIO Now!. Can NOT use iPAQ expansion
sleeves.